Appraisers and pricing analysts estimate a home's market value by triangulating three standard approaches: the sales comparison approach, the cost approach, and the income approach. For single-family homes the sales comparison approach dominates, which is why the same handful of inputs recur in almost every valuation.
The sales comparison approach starts with market comps: three to six recent sales of similar homes, ideally closed within the last three to six months and within roughly a half mile. The appraiser then makes dollar adjustments for every material difference — square footage, bedroom and bathroom count, lot size, garage, condition, and updates — until the comps resemble the subject property. The adjusted values are averaged and reconciled into a final opinion of value.
Location factors are applied on top of the comps. School district ratings, commute times, walkability, safety, views, flood-zone status, and even street-level noise can justify adjustments of 5% to 20% or more between otherwise identical homes. This is why the same floor plan can differ by hundreds of thousands of dollars across two ZIP codes a few miles apart.
Historical price trends set the backdrop. Appraisers weigh the direction and pace of the local market: how fast prices have appreciated over the past one to three years, how many days homes sit on market, and whether the market currently favors buyers or sellers. A rising market supports the upper end of the comp range; a cooling market pulls the estimate toward the lower end.
Finally comes reconciliation — deciding how much weight each comp deserves to land on a single value. Price-per-square-foot is the fastest sanity check across that whole process, which is why it appears on every card in this game.